Stablecoins are the backbone of the crypto economy, and Tether (USDT) reigns supreme. With a daily trading volume exceeding $100 billion—nearly double that of Bitcoin—USDT has become the de facto settlement currency across exchanges and over-the-counter (OTC) markets. But amid its dominance, persistent questions linger: Is USDT truly backed 1:1 by USD? Can it always be redeemed for real dollars? And is it safe?
This article dives into the mechanics of USDT, the controversies surrounding its reserves, the landmark legal battle with the New York Attorney General (NYAG), and what it all means for investors today.
What Is USDT?
USDT, issued by Tether Limited, is a fiat-collateralized stablecoin designed to maintain a 1:1 parity with the U.S. dollar. For every USDT in circulation, there should theoretically be one U.S. dollar—or equivalent asset—held in reserve.
Tether operates under the umbrella of iFinex Inc., which also owns the cryptocurrency exchange Bitfinex. This corporate relationship has been central to many of the controversies surrounding USDT’s transparency and solvency.
As of 2025, Tether has issued over 24.7 billion USDT, dwarfing competitors like USDC, which holds a significantly smaller market share. Its widespread adoption makes USDT the most liquid stablecoin, forming the basis of countless trading pairs on global exchanges.
👉 Discover how leading platforms manage stablecoin liquidity and risk.
Why Is USDT So Controversial?
Despite its dominance, USDT has faced years of scrutiny over whether it’s fully backed and whether its issuance influences crypto market prices.
The 2017 Surge and Market Manipulation Theories
In early 2017, USDT’s supply was just $100 million. By February 2018, it had ballooned to $2.2 billion—an exponential rise that coincided with Bitcoin’s historic bull run. Critics alleged that Tether was printing unbacked USDT to buy Bitcoin and artificially inflate prices.
While correlation doesn’t imply causation, the timing fueled suspicion. Some researchers suggested that new USDT issuances often preceded major BTC rallies, raising red flags about market manipulation.
However, others argue the demand for USDT grew organically as traders sought a stable medium during volatile periods—especially in regions with capital controls or limited banking access.
The Audit Dilemma: Where’s the Proof?
One of the biggest criticisms of Tether has been its lack of transparent, real-time audits.
In 2017, Tether released a limited attestation from Friedman LLP, confirming that it held assets equal to its issued USDT at a specific point in time. However, this was not a full audit—it didn’t verify the source of funds or confirm that reserves were liquid or entirely composed of cash.
Later statements claimed Tether remained “fully solvent,” but without independent verification, skepticism persisted.
“Transparency is not optional when you're the foundation of trillions in crypto transactions.”
— Blockchain analyst comment on Tether’s reporting practices
Even today, while Tether publishes quarterly reserve breakdowns, these are attestations—not audits—and include non-cash assets like commercial paper and corporate bonds.
The NYAG Lawsuit: A Crisis of Trust
The most serious challenge to Tether’s credibility came in April 2019, when the New York Attorney General (NYAG) sued Bitfinex and Tether.
What Happened?
Bitfinex lost access to approximately $850 million held through a payment processor, Crypto Capital Corp., which had its accounts frozen by regulators due to alleged money laundering and misuse of client funds.
To cover the shortfall, Bitfinex allegedly borrowed $675 million from Tether’s reserves—effectively using customer-protected stablecoin backing to bail out the exchange.
This violated Tether’s promise of 100% cash reserves and shattered trust in its operational independence.
Reserve Transparency Crumbles
During the investigation, Tether admitted that at one point, only 74% of USDT was backed by actual cash or cash equivalents. The remainder included loans to affiliated companies and other less liquid assets.
This revelation intensified fears: if a massive redemption event occurred, could Tether actually honor withdrawals?
In April 2020, Tether announced it had restored full backing—though now defined as 100% in total assets, not necessarily cash.
Can You Still Redeem USDT for USD?
Yes—but with caveats.
Major exchanges like OKX, Binance, and Kraken regularly redeem large volumes of USDT for fiat through direct channels with Tether. These institutions have verified redemption capabilities, which supports market confidence.
Sam Bankman-Fried, former CEO of FTX, once dismissed concerns by saying:
“It sounds kind of silly to say you can’t redeem USDT. I don’t know how else to put it—you literally can, because we do it all the time.”
But retail users face more friction. Direct redemption through Tether is typically reserved for institutional clients with minimum thresholds (e.g., $100,000+). Most individuals rely on exchanges or OTC desks to convert USDT to USD.
👉 See how top exchanges streamline USDT-to-USD conversions for high-volume traders.
Who Uses USDT—and Why?
Beyond speculation and trading, USDT plays a critical role in cross-border finance.
OTC Markets and Capital Controls
In countries with strict capital controls—like China—USDT serves as a workaround for moving money across borders. Despite China’s ban on cryptocurrency trading, USDT remains widely used because it’s not explicitly prohibited.
According to Chainalysis, China is among the largest markets for USDT purchases. Businesses and individuals buy millions of dollars worth daily to bypass foreign exchange limits (capped at $50,000 per person annually).
For example:
- A Chinese company earns USD abroad but faces restrictions repatriating funds.
- It sells those dollars locally for USDT via an OTC desk in Moscow or Hong Kong.
- The USDT is then transferred digitally and sold domestically for CNY—bypassing state controls.
Moscow-based OTC trader Maya Shakhnazarova noted:
“Customers bring cash in, we send them USDT instantly. It’s fast, simple, and private.”
This use case underscores why demand for USDT continues to grow—even amid regulatory uncertainty.
Current State: Is USDT Safe Now?
As of 2025, Tether claims its reserves are fully backed and more diversified than ever:
- Cash & cash equivalents
- U.S. Treasury bills
- Secured loans
- Corporate bonds
Quarterly attestations provide some transparency, but without full audits or real-time reserve tracking, risks remain—especially during financial stress.
Still, the ecosystem depends on USDT’s stability. Exchanges monitor redemptions closely, and major players have contingency plans in place.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Q: Is USDT fully backed by real dollars?
A: Not entirely in cash. As of recent reports, USDT is backed 1:1 by total assets—including cash, Treasuries, and short-term debt—but not purely by physical USD.
Q: Can I personally redeem 1 USDT for $1?
A: Retail users usually can’t redeem directly with Tether. Instead, use licensed exchanges or OTC desks that offer USD withdrawals.
Q: Could USDT collapse and take down crypto markets?
A: A loss of confidence in USDT could trigger massive sell-offs. However, increased competition from regulated stablecoins like USDC may reduce systemic risk over time.
Q: Why doesn’t Tether publish full audits?
A: Tether cites client privacy and competitive sensitivity. Third-party attestations are released quarterly instead.
Q: Is holding USDT riskier than holding USD in a bank?
A: Yes. Unlike FDIC-insured bank deposits, USDT carries counterparty, regulatory, and liquidity risks—even if minimal under normal conditions.
Q: What happens if another lawsuit targets Tether?
A: Legal actions could restrict operations or force asset liquidations. However, Tether has weathered past challenges and adapted its reserve structure accordingly.
Final Thoughts
The debate over USDT’s legitimacy isn’t just academic—it strikes at the heart of crypto’s financial infrastructure. While concerns about transparency and past reserve shortfalls are valid, current evidence suggests that USDT remains redeemable and functionally stable under normal market conditions.
Its unparalleled liquidity and global adoption make it indispensable—for better or worse. As regulatory frameworks evolve, so too will expectations for accountability.
For now, investors should treat USDT as a high-convenience, moderate-risk tool—not a perfect substitute for regulated fiat banking.
👉 Stay ahead with real-time insights on stablecoin stability and market shifts.