The cryptocurrency world is no stranger to controversy, but few claims stir as much debate as the idea that Ethereum (ETH)—the second-largest digital asset by market cap—could one day be worth nothing at all. In early September 2018, a provocative article by Jeremy Rubin, a well-known blockchain developer and Bitcoin core contributor, reignited fears among investors when he boldly predicted: “ETH will go to zero.”
But is this doomsday forecast grounded in real technical concerns—or simply a strategic narrative to influence market sentiment? Let’s break down the arguments, examine the context, and separate fear from facts.
The Controversial Claim: "ETH Will Become Worthless"
In an opinion piece published on TechCrunch, Rubin argued that while the Ethereum network may survive and even thrive as a decentralized platform, the native token ETH could eventually lose all value. His reasoning centered on three key issues:
- Failure to Scale Effectively
Despite years of development, Ethereum has struggled with congestion and high gas fees during peak usage—problems that hinder mass adoption. - Lack of Safer Smart Contract Standards
Numerous exploits and hacks (e.g., The DAO attack) have exposed vulnerabilities in Ethereum’s contract ecosystem. - Intense Competition from Other Blockchains
Platforms like EOS, Cardano, and later Solana began positioning themselves as faster, cheaper alternatives to Ethereum.
Rubin concluded that if Ethereum transitions fully to a fee-burning model (where transaction fees are destroyed rather than paid to miners), there would be no fundamental need to hold ETH long-term—potentially collapsing its monetary value.
“I predict the Ethereum network will persist, but the asset ETH will go to zero.”
This bold statement sent shockwaves through the crypto community—and not surprisingly, drew an immediate response from Ethereum’s co-founder.
Vitalik Buterin Fights Back
Vitalik Buterin, affectionately known as “V神” in the crypto space, swiftly pushed back against Rubin’s claims. In a detailed rebuttal, he acknowledged some of the criticisms but emphasized ongoing upgrades designed to future-proof the network.
Buterin pointed out that Ethereum was already working on two major proposals—EIP-1559 and proof-of-stake (via the upcoming Serenity upgrade)—that would actually increase demand for ETH by making it integral to network security and transaction settlement.
Moreover, under EIP-1559 (which eventually launched in 2021), a portion of ETH used in transactions is permanently burned, reducing supply over time. This creates deflationary pressure—a strong counterargument to the “ETH goes to zero” thesis.
👉 Discover how Ethereum's evolution continues to shape the future of decentralized finance.
Market Reality: Volatility vs. Long-Term Value
At the time of Rubin’s comments in 2018, Ethereum had already lost over 80% of its value from its previous highs. A sharp 20% drop within 12 hours in August intensified investor anxiety. Many attributed the sell-off to large holders—often project teams or early investors—dumping ETH to fund operations amid a broader bear market.
While short-term price swings can be influenced by fear and speculation, long-term value depends on adoption, utility, and innovation.
Fast forward to today, Ethereum has undergone transformative changes:
- Successfully completed The Merge in 2022, shifting from proof-of-work to proof-of-stake.
- Significantly reduced energy consumption by over 99%.
- Continued leadership in decentralized applications (dApps), NFTs, and DeFi protocols.
These developments strongly contradict the idea that ETH lacks intrinsic value.
Why Do Experts Make Bold Predictions?
It’s important to ask: Why would a respected developer make such a controversial claim?
Possible motivations include:
- Highlighting real technical risks to prompt action within the community.
- Influencing market dynamics—whether consciously or unconsciously.
- Promoting alternative blockchain solutions they’re involved with.
Regardless of intent, bearish commentary often leads to temporary price drops due to panic selling—especially among retail investors who may not fully understand the underlying technology.
But history shows that Ethereum has weathered multiple “death predictions” before—and emerged stronger each time.
Core Keywords Driving the Conversation
To better align with search intent and improve SEO visibility, here are the core keywords naturally embedded throughout this discussion:
- Ethereum price prediction
- ETH to zero
- Vitalik Buterin response
- Ethereum network upgrade
- Cryptocurrency market crash
- Blockchain scalability
- Smart contract security
- Decentralized finance (DeFi)
These terms reflect what users are actively searching for when evaluating Ethereum’s future.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Q: Can ETH really go to zero?
A: While theoretically possible for any asset, it's highly unlikely for ETH given its widespread use in DeFi, NFTs, and enterprise blockchain solutions. Network activity and developer engagement remain strong indicators of long-term viability.
Q: Did Jeremy Rubin’s prediction come true?
A: No. As of 2025, ETH has not only retained value but evolved into a foundational layer for Web3 applications. His warning served more as a critique than a prophecy.
Q: What makes ETH valuable?
A: ETH is required to pay transaction fees and interact with smart contracts on the Ethereum network. With upgrades like EIP-1559 introducing deflationary mechanics, scarcity adds further economic weight.
Q: Is Ethereum still relevant amid new blockchains?
A: Absolutely. Despite competition, Ethereum maintains the largest developer community and ecosystem of dApps. Layer-2 scaling solutions also address past performance issues.
Q: How did The Merge affect ETH’s value?
A: By transitioning to proof-of-stake, Ethereum became more energy-efficient and introduced staking rewards. This shifted ETH from being purely speculative to an income-generating asset for many holders.
👉 Learn how next-gen blockchain platforms are redefining digital ownership and finance.
Looking Ahead: Ethereum’s Path Beyond 2025
Rather than fading into irrelevance, Ethereum continues to innovate. Key developments include:
- Rollups and Layer-2 networks improving speed and lowering costs.
- Ongoing research into sharding for greater scalability.
- Institutional interest growing through ETH ETFs and regulated financial products.
Even critics now acknowledge that Ethereum is more than just a cryptocurrency—it's an evolving digital economy.
While short-term volatility will always exist in crypto markets, dismissing ETH entirely ignores the massive infrastructure built around it.
Final Thoughts: Hype or Substance?
Claims that ETH will go to zero tap into legitimate concerns about scalability and competition—but they overlook Ethereum’s resilience, adaptability, and first-mover advantage in smart contract platforms.
Bearish opinions play a role in healthy discourse, pushing developers to improve and investors to think critically. But so far, every existential threat has led not to collapse, but to reinvention.
For those seeking long-term exposure to blockchain innovation, Ethereum remains one of the most compelling assets in the space—not because it's perfect, but because it keeps evolving.
👉 Stay ahead of market trends with real-time data and insights on next-generation digital assets.